Recommended Conservation Measures from the South Carolina Field Office
Hibernating Range
- Report any dead bats found during or after activities have commenced to the Service immediately.
Tree Clearing
- Avoid standing tree removal during the summer occupancy period (April 1 to September 30). If tree removal during that time needs to occur, avoid pupping season (May 15 to July 31). Ideally tree removal should during the hibernation period (November 16 to March 31), outside of the active season for tree-roosting bats. The timing of standing tree removal and the number of acres removed should be included in a final report.
- Avoid removing suitable roost trees within 0.25-mile of a known NLEB and/or TCB hibernaculum entrance(s) during spring staging (April 1 to May 14) and fall swarming (September 1 to November 15).
- Avoid removing suitable roost trees within 0.25-mile of a known NLEB and/or TCB hibernaculum during pupping season (May 15 to July 31).
- Snags should be retained where possible across the landscape, when not a safety hazard.
Transportation Structure Work
- Structures (bridges and/or culverts ≥36” diameter) should be modified or demolished during hibernation period (November 16 to March 31), outside the bat active season. Bats are not expected to occupy these types of structures during the hibernation period.
- Prior to any structure maintenance or demolition, a qualified biologist should inspect structures for evidence of bat use and submit report to the Service. If a survey was conducted more than 30 days prior to work on the structure, then it should be re-surveyed within 14 days prior to work on the structure. If bats are present, further discussions with the Service will be needed regarding how to proceed. No work will begin at the structure location until discussions with the Service have concluded.
- If bat evidence or bat sightings are unexpectedly made during structure maintenance or demolition, the contractor will stop work and the Service will be notified immediately. No work will resume at the structure location until discussions with the Service have concluded.
Prescribed Fire
- Avoid moderate to high-severity prescribed fire.
- Priority should be to conduct prescribed fires during the hibernation season (November 16 to March 31).
- If conducting prescribed fire during the active season (April 1 to May 14 and August 1 to November 15), the pupping season (May 15 to July 31) should be completely avoided. Prescribed fires in the active season should occur when the minimum air temperature is above 40°F.
- Avoid smoke influences on hibernaculum when bats may be present by using methods and strategies that will achieve this objective including but not limited to, designation of hibernacula as smoke-sensitive receptors in prescribed fire burn plans.
Disturbance
- Avoid activities resulting in the disruption or disturbance of NLEB and/or TCB in their hibernacula during hibernation.
- Avoid activities resulting in adverse effects to NLEB and/or TCB hibernaculum entrance(s) or internal environments (e.g., adverse alterations to airflow, microclimate, and hydrology) at any time of year.
- Avoid work activities that will cause chronic noise from one half hour before official sunset times until one half hour after official sunrise times, during the summer occupancy period (April 1 through September 30). Note: Chronic noise is noise that is continuous or occurs repeatedly again and again for a long time.
- Avoid the use of artificial lighting within 1000 feet of suitable NLEB & TCB roosting habitat from one half hour before official sunset times until one half hour after official sunrise times, during the summer occupancy period (April 1 through September 30).
- Use downcast lighting in residential areas during the design review process where practical. The use of downcast lighting in residential areas will aid in long-term disturbance to the bats nighttime behavior.
Year-Round Active Range
- Report any dead bats found during or after activities have commenced to the Service immediately.
Tree Clearing
- Tree removal should occur outside of the two sensitive seasons, winter torpor (December 15 to February 15) and pupping season (May 1 to July 15). The timing of standing tree removal and the number of acres removed should be included in a final report.
- Snags should be retained where possible across the landscape, when not a safety hazard.
Transportation Structure Work
- Structures (bridges and/or culverts ≥36” diameter) should be modified or demolished outside of the two sensitive seasons, winter torpor (December 15 to February 15) and pupping season (May 1 to July 15).
- *If gray bats are expected to occur in the area, modifications or demolition of structure should occur during the hibernation season (November 16 to March 31). Gray bats are expected to return to out-of-state caves during this period.
- Prior to any structure (bridges and/or culverts ≥36” diameter) maintenance or demolition, a qualified biologist should inspect structures for evidence of bat use and submit report to the Service. If a survey was conducted more than 30 days prior to work on the structure, then it should be re-surveyed within 14 days prior to work on the structure. If bats are present, further discussions with the Service will be needed regarding how to proceed. No work will begin at the structure location until discussions with the Service have concluded.
- If bat evidence or bat sightings are unexpectedly made during structure maintenance or demolition, the contractor will stop work and the Service will be notified immediately. No work will resume at the structure location until discussions with the Service have concluded.
Prescribed Fire
- Avoid moderate to high-severity prescribed fire.
- Priority should be to conduct prescribed fires outside of the two sensitive seasons, winter torpor (December 15 to February 15) and pupping season (May 1 to July 15).
- If conducting prescribed fire during winter torpor (December 15 to February 15), the prescribed fire should occur when the minimum air temperature is above 40°F.
Disturbance
- Avoid work activities that will cause chronic noise from one half hour before official sunset times until one half hour after official sunrise times. Note: Chronic noise is noise that is continuous or occurs repeatedly again and again for a long time.
- Avoid the use of artificial lighting within 1000 feet of suitable roosting habitat from one half hour before official sunset times until one half hour after official sunrise times.
- Use downcast lighting in residential areas during the design review process where practical. The use of downcast lighting in residential areas will aid in long-term disturbance to the bats nighttime behavior.
- Instream work should be minimized to the smallest footprint practicable.
- Appropriate erosion and sediment control devices should be installed before work begins and maintained throughout the repair.
- Work activities should be conducted from a stable streambank or reinforced platform that does not cause streambank destabilization or degradation.
- Work that involves disturbance of the channel should be conducted in the dry via a rock (or Hydrabarrier) berm and pump around system.
- All remnants of the damaged structure should be removed from the streambed and disposed of at an approved, offsite disposal area. Bridge remnants or other flood debris should not be utilized for streambank stabilization.
- If instream access is required, we recommend the use of temporary pads of clean riprap or wood with no earth fill. Fill material must not be taken from the streambed. Riprap or wood should be removed following construction activity, and the streambed restored to original condition. Flow and aquatic organism passage should be maintained at all times during repair activities.
- Equipment and utilities crossings, if necessary, should be accomplished perpendicular to streams whenever possible.
- Staging, refueling, and maintenance areas should not be located near streams, riparian zones, and wetlands. Equipment should be stored, serviced, and fueled in an upland area, away from aquatic habitats or other sensitive areas. Equipment that is not easily moved offsite (e.g., cranes), and all equipment parked near streams, riparian zones, and wetlands overnight or for any period of inactivity, such as weekends, should have oil absorbent booms (“diapers”) affixed to prevent accidental fluid leakage.
- Where bridge replacements are required, the applicant should consider a full span or reducing the number of instream piers from the original design to benefit listed species and their habitats, improve hydraulic capacity, and minimize long-term maintenance issues (e.g. pier scour and undermining, debris buildup, etc.).
- Avoid scuppers or other direct drainage of road surfaces into the stream.
- Applicants should consider installation of a bottomless culvert or a span design in the place of pipes or box culverts. If this is not feasible due to substrate composition, we recommend that the culvert be counter sunk below the substrate, and that the culvert width be 1.2 times the bankfull width. The culvert slope should match the channel grade.
- Fresh concrete and cement dust must be kept out of the water as they alter chemical properties and can be toxic to aquatic species.
- Disturbed surfaces should be restored to original contours and excess materials removed to a properly confined upland area. All disturbed areas should be stabilized as soon as possible with use of native vegetation or clean riprap, as appropriate.
- A qualified biologist should survey the area for the presence of Eastern Black Rail or optimal habitat features. Educate personnel on avoiding areas being used by birds.
- Avoid all disturbances during the sensitive timeframes (nesting, brooding, or flightless molt periods): April 1 through October 31, with nesting peaking the third week of June
- Disturbances include:
- Habitat fragmentation, alteration, or destruction of habitat
- Ditching or changes to hydrology that would lead to the loss of habitat
- Prescribed fire, haying, mowing, grazing and mechanical treatments
- Replacing water control structures
- At all times, vehicle and foot traffic should not occur within 150 feet of the birds or within 10 feet of optimal habitat features.
- The recommended buffers should be maintained for the duration of the work activities even if the birds depart or relocate. Personnel and vehicles should follow existing/ established travel and access corridors and maintain slow speeds to avoid disturbing birds.
Prescribed fire and other treatments:
- The application of prescribed fire should avoid perimeter fires, ring fires, or fires that have long, unbroken boundaries that prevent species dependent on dense cover from escaping a fire.
- Prescribed fire should move slowly across a tract. Fast fires can cause significant mortality for eastern black rails.
- Prescribed fire should be applied in a patchy manner or with small patches to allow eastern black rails a place of refuge. Patches can be small but numerous enough to support multiple eastern black rails.
- Haying, mowing, and mechanical treatment activities should avoid emergent wetlands, should provide untreated (i.e., unmown or avoided) areas that provide refugia for species dependent on dense cover, such as the eastern black rail, and participants should use temporary markers to identify where birds occur, for example wetland areas, so that these areas may be avoided.
- Feral pigs and phragmites are invasive species that need to be controlled for effective management of Eastern Black Rail habitat. Feral pigs can be controlled by lethal methods (trapping, snaring, shooting) or non-lethal methods (fencing). Phragmites can be controlled with fire, mowing, excavation, or chemical treatment.
- A qualified biologist should survey the area for the presence of Frosted Flatwoods Salamanders or optimal habitat features.
- Avoid ditching wetlands to connect to other bodies of water, which can potentially drain the wetland and introduce fish.
- Ground disturbance within ephemeral wetlands should be avoided and kept to a minimum when unavoidable.
- Ephemeral wetland vegetation should be managed with fire during the growing season to avoid salamanders during their movement periods. Using fire minimizes mechanical disturbance while minimizing the use of herbicides that could affect salamander forage. Mechanical treatments with handheld equipment (e.g., brush saws and chainsaws) may also be used to successfully reduce canopy cover and facilitate herbaceous vegetation growth.
- Feral pigs pose a significant threat to Frosted Flatwoods Salamanders due to their rooting and omnivorous behaviors. Feral pigs can be controlled by lethal methods (trapping, snaring, shooting) or non-lethal methods (fencing).
- When constructing roads efforts should be made to enable salamander migration using culverts under the roadway to reduce roadway mortality. Roads should also be constructed to minimize disturbance to groundwater flow around breeding ponds.
To reduce potential construction-related impacts to manatees to discountable and insignificant levels, the Service recommends implementing the following Manatee Protection Measures to all projects affecting the coastal waters of South Carolina.
The permittee will comply with the following construction conditions for manatee protection:
- The permittee shall ensure all personnel associated with the project are informed that there are civil and criminal penalties for harming, harassing, or killing manatees, which are protected under the Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972 and the Endangered Species Act of 1973. The permittee and the permittee’s contractors will be held responsible for any manatee harmed, harassed, or killed as a result of construction activities.
- The permittee shall instruct all personnel associated with the project of the potential presence of manatees and the need to avoid collisions. Personnel must be trained to recognize manatees, and must remain continuously aware, monitoring all water-related activities for the presence of manatees.
- If manatees are observed within 100 yards of the active construction area, all appropriate precautions shall be implemented to ensure their protection. These precautions include operating all moving equipment no closer than 50 feet to a manatee. Should a manatee approach to within 50 feet, all in-water construction activities shall cease immediately. Work may only resume once the manatee has voluntarily left the area, or 30 minutes have passed without reappearance. Under no circumstances shall manatees be herded or harassed into leaving.
- All vessels associated with the project shall operate at “no wake/idle” speeds at all times while within the construction area and in any water where the vessel’s draft provides less than four feet of clearance from the bottom. All vessels shall follow routes through deep water when entering or exiting the project area, and whenever possible while operating within the project area.
- Extreme care shall be taken when lowering equipment and materials below the water surface or to the bottom. Equipment and materials include, but are not limited to: piles, sheet piles, casings for drilled shaft construction, spuds, pile templates, and anchors. All such equipment and materials shall be lowered as slowly as possible to avoid injury to any manatee that may have entered the project area undetected.
- Siltation and turbidity barriers must not impede manatee movement. Siltation barriers shall not be installed below the high tide line and must remain visible at all times. Any barriers used during the project shall be made of materials in which manatees cannot become entangled and must be properly secured and regularly monitored to prevent manatee entrapment.
- The permittee understands and agrees that all in-water lines (including rope, chain, and cable, such as those used to secure turbidity barriers) must be stiff, taut, and non-looping. Acceptable examples include heavy metal chains or cables that do not readily loop or tangle. Flexible in-water lines, such as nylon rope or any lines that could loop or tangle, must be enclosed in a plastic or rubber sleeve or tube to add rigidity and prevent entanglement. In all instances, no excess line shall be allowed in the water. Where appropriate, in-water wires and cables should be fitted with a PVC sleeve from the surface to the bottom to prevent potential scraping of passing manatees.
- All culverts 8 inches to 8 feet in diameter must be grated to prevent manatee entrapment. To effectively prevent manatee access, grates must be permanently fixed, spaced a maximum of 8 inches apart (may be less for culverts smaller than 16 inches in diameter) and may be installed diagonally, horizontally or vertically. For new culverts, grates must be attached prior to installation of the culverts. Culverts less than 8 inches or greater than 8 feet in diameter are exempt from this requirement.
- The permittee shall regularly inspect and maintain all hoses, faucets, and other potential sources of freshwater to ensure that any leaks are promptly stopped and repaired. Manatees are strongly attracted to freshwater leaking from dock facilities, which often coincide with areas of concentrated boat traffic, increasing the risk of collisions. To minimize this risk, inspections should occur daily during active construction and whenever freshwater systems are in use. Any detected leaks must be repaired immediately, and temporary measures such as shutting off water sources should be implemented until permanent repairs are completed. Additionally, personnel should be trained to recognize signs of manatee presence near freshwater discharge points and take appropriate precautions, including reducing vessel speed and avoiding in-water operations when manatees are nearby.
- For facilities with oil or gas pumps and/or sewage pump-out equipment, the permittee shall maintain a spill contingency plan and report all spills to South Carolina Department of Environmental Services (https://des.sc.gov/about-scdes/contact-us/reporting-chemical-spills-oil-spills-and-fish-kills). The plan must include immediate spill response procedures, measures to prevent contamination, and protocols to minimize risks to manatees. Regular inspections of pumps, hoses, and connections should be conducted to identify and correct leaks promptly.
- All temporary or unused construction materials shall be removed from the project area upon completion of the work, and any impacted areas of salt marsh upon project completion, and impacted salt marsh areas restored. No debris or trash shall be discarded in the project area or adjacent waters. Restoration shall include regrading, replanting native vegetation, and erosion control to protect manatee habitats.
- The permittee shall ensure that the contractor reports all manatee sightings online to the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR) Manatee Sighting Form (https://www.dnr.sc.gov/manatee/sight.htm).
- Any collision with or injury to a manatee shall be reported immediately to:
- SCDNR Wildlife Hotline: 1-800-922-5431
- USFWS South Carolina Ecological Services Field Office: 843-727-4707
Temporary manatee awareness signs are encouraged at project sites to increase awareness among personnel and the public. Please reach out to SCDNR at manatee@dnr.sc.gov for more information.
- A qualified biologist should survey the area for the presence of Monarch Butterflies or optimal habitat features.
Minimum Standards:
- Seed mixes will include a minimum of 9 total species of native flowering plants including 3 species per blooming periods of April to June, June to July, and August to October.
- Seed mixes will seek to be free of invasive or aggressive non-native species that inhibit diversity when established. When including milkweed species, seed mixes will include regionally appropriate native species and must avoid using tropical milkweed or other non-native species.
Recommended:
- Schedule mowing to enhance floral resources.
- Follow regional planting guides specific to ecoregion and source seeds as locally as possible, with consideration for climate adaptation.
- Remove plants that are invasive or listed as noxious weeds (by using techniques including targeted herbicide, prescribed burns, as appropriate).
- When conducting forestry using ecological principles, create openings of various sizes that promote herbaceous understory plant communities. In pine and/or oak woodlands and savannas, use prescribed fire to maintain those conditions important for monarch butterflies and other pollinators.
- Use buffer areas for forests adjacent to roadways, mow infrequently, and create native plant communities to improve transition zone between forest and roads.
- Limit insecticide exposure where possible, using established Integrated Pest Management guidance and/or approved Pesticide Use Permits.
- Use of herbicides should be monitored to avoid spraying areas of milk weed and appropriate nectar plants.
Special note about wintering (approximately November 15th- March 15th): Overwintering is limited to scattered locations along the coast, including Sullivan’s Island, Folly Beach, and Isle of Palms. Monarchs during this period are largely roosting in trees and shrubs in barrier island and maritime forest habitats. Overwintering monarchs tend to become more active in warmer weather (60-70 degrees Fahrenheit) and nectar on flowering resources nearby (usually planted flowers in developed areas).
Recommended measures if overwintering is observed:
- Avoid disturbances to trees where large numbers of monarchs are congregated.
- Limit insecticide and herbicide use.
- A qualified Biologist or Botanist should survey the area for the presence of species during the most optimum time depending on the species. Survey windows for listing plants can be found below. For most species, survey is good for 3 years. For seabeach amaranth, survey is only good for 1 year.
- High-visibility fencing should be placed around listed plant sites to ensure there will be no accidental encroachment.
- No access or staging areas should be permitted within listed plant sites.
- Projects should be designed to avoid and leave listed plants within the project footprint undisturbed.
- Any listed plants in the project footprint that cannot be left undisturbed should be relocated, during the dormant season, to suitable habitat outside the project footprint. The Service should be contacted to help develop a relocation plan. Relocation plans should include follow up monitoring during the spring following translocation. Contact the Service for help developing a relocation plan.
- Permanent conservation easements should be established to protect listed plants in perpetuity, if possible.
- Invasive non-native plant species across the site should be monitored post-construction for five years, especially along the interface between construction activities and protected plant populations. If any non-native plant species start spreading into the protected area of site, they should be removed or treated. If herbicide is used to control invasive non-native plants, a barrier (such as cardboard or plastic) will be used to protect any listed plants located within 15 feet of herbicide treatment areas. Herbicides will not be used on days with high winds.
- No broadcast spraying of herbicides, no fertilizers. Spot herbicide treatment can be used as needed with protection of the listed plants to prohibit off-target impacts.
Prescribed fire
- Prescribed burns should occur during the dormant season.
- If possible, a botanist or qualified individual who can identify the listed plant should be available to flag the listed plants prior to the burn; direct the fire crew to rake around listed plants and cut back large, overtopping vegetation; stay present until active fire moves away from the plants.
- Limit the number of fire specialists needed for safety that enter the vicinity of the listed plants to minimize trampling.
Please follow this link to see the optimal survey windows for listed plants:
Survey windows for South Carolina's federally threatened, endangered, and at-risk plant species
The following information provides conservation measures, descriptions of activities that may adversely affect the species, habitat assessment guidance, and survey recommendations derived from the 2003 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) Red-cockaded (RCW) Recovery Plan and South Carolina Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR) Safe Harbor Program. Each project should be evaluated individually to determine which conservation measures and survey efforts are appropriate to avoid, minimize, or assess potential effects to the species. For additional detail and guidance, refer to the RCW Recovery Plan.
General Conservation Measures
- The Service strongly recommends avoiding and preserving occupied habitat whenever possible. If feasible, modify the project footprint to avoid direct impacts to RCW and their habitat. Building plans should be adjusted to retain large pines. Habitat may also be designated as an environmentally sensitive area and protected through a deed restriction, conservation easement, or other long-term protective covenant.
- If occupied habitat is present on‑site, develop a habitat management plan.
- Do not conduct work within 200 feet of cavity trees during the nesting season (April 1 – July 31) and within 50 feet the remainder of the year.
- Maintain sufficient residual pine basal area and acreage to meet and maintain the minimum foraging standards. Minimum foraging standards are relative to the Standard for Managed Stability or Recovery Standard, as appropriate, described in Habitat Management Conservation Measures.
- Avoid herbicide use that would reduce habitat below RCW standards or damage cavity trees. Use herbicides selectively to support habitat objectives.
- Remove vines and thick underbrush/mid-story to improve habitat suitability.
- Mark all cavity trees clearly to ensure they easily identified and to reduce the risk of accidental damage or removal.
- Protect existing cavity trees against fire damage.
- Reduce fuels for a minimum distance of 10 ft (3 m) of the base of each cavity tree.
- Rake leaf litter away from trunk and use low intensity backing fire when burning within cavity clusters.
- Adjust the fuel‑reduction distance based on fuel type, fuel load, resin levels, cavity height, firing technique, and burn objectives.
- Apply greater fuel‑reduction distances for restoration burns than for routine maintenance burns.
- Use maximum distances during the nesting season and for trees with turpentine scars or resin low on the bole.
- Maintain regular, frequent prescribed fire within clusters
- Protect cavity tree roots.
- Prohibit the use of heavy equipment and vehicles within 50 ft (15.25 m) of cavity trees.
- Do not operate machinery within 50 ft (15.25 m) in wet areas.
- Do not establish plow lines within 200 ft (61 m) of cavity trees.
- Reduce risk of southern pine beetle infestation by thinning loblolly or shortleaf pine stands to 50–80 ft²/ac basal area.
- Reduce risk of wind damage by maintaining a 200 ft buffer of continuous forest around each cluster of cavity trees.
- Guidelines for Cluster and Cavity Trees
- Develop sufficient large and old pines to serve as cavity trees. Retain all potential cavity trees (pines > 60 years) within clusters, unless pine basal area is above 50 ft2 /ac. Supply trees for future cavity trees and clusters in abundance. Grow large, old pines throughout the landscape. If potential cavity trees are rare, consider protecting from fire, root damage, and other potential risks as described in the 2003 Recovery Plan.
- Restore and maintain appropriate habitat structure.
- Control hardwood/pine midstory. Apply prescribed fire to entire cluster every 1-5 years, during growing season.
- Foster native grasses and forbs. Apply frequent growing season fire and avoid soil disturbance.
- Reduce excessive overstory hardwoods within cluster. These trees should not total > 10 ft2 /ac in basal area.
- Locate recruitment clusters away from stream drainages whenever possible.
- Retain dead and dying cavity trees and all other snags unless they present a safety hazard.
- Reduce human disturbance within clusters as much as possible, especially during nesting season.
- Restrict vehicle use to existing roads. Avoid construction of new roads, trails, campsites, etc. within clusters.
- Limit silvicultural and cultural operations to daylight hours; avoid within 1-2 hours of dawn and dusk.
- Mechanized equipment in a cluster is permitted during non-breeding season for red-cockaded woodpecker management activities only.
- Habitat management activities other than prescribed burning are prohibited during breeding season (April 1 – July 31).
- Enroll the property into the South Carolina RCW Safe Harbor Program.
- Any non-federal or state property in South Carolina that falls within the historic range is eligible for enrollment. However, all enrolled properties and the habitat management performed on those properties must provide an overall conservation benefit to RCW.
- The goals of the program are to maintain and enhance RCW populations on private properties through voluntary land management commitments by landowners. to help South Carolina landowners by removing some of the regulatory restrictions imposed by the ESA, and to provide benefits to other plants and animals that inhabit pine uplands.
- The Safe Harbor Program is interested in properties that meet one or more of the following situations, (1) The property is currently occupied by RCW (partially or entirely) for nesting and/or foraging, (2) The property contains historical records of RCW occupation, or (3) A property contains longleaf, loblolly, and/or pond pine stands that are at least 30 years old.
- The Landowner is responsible for enhancing and maintaining currently existing RCW nesting/foraging habitat (if present), performing additional habitat enhancement activities on the property and coordinating and cooperating with SCDNR and any other authorized biologists or consultants.
Habitat Management Conservation Measures
The habitat management conservation measures described herein are intended to avoid take of RCW under ESA Section 9 and to ensure compliance with the species 4(d) rule, including activities conducted under Safe Harbor agreements, Conservation Benefit Agreements, etc.
Guidelines for Foraging Habitat
- The Standard for Managed Stability. To ensure any project is not likely to adversely affect the RCW, the project proponent must manage at the Standard for Managed Stability. This standard is not designed to increase population size. Federal Agencies should manage at or toward the Recovery Standard. Private landowners are strongly encouraged to manage at or toward the Recovery Standard and should provide at least the Standard for Managed Stability.
- Provide each group of RCW a minimum of 689 m2 (3000 ft2) of pine basal area, including only pines > 25.4 cm (10 in) dbh.
- Provide the above pine basal area on a minimum of 30.4 ha (75 ac).
- Count only those pine stands in suitable habitat that, for this standard only, has each of the following characteristics:
- Stands that are at least 30 years old and older.
- An average pine basal area of pines >25.4 cm (10 in) between 9.2 and 16.1 m2/ha (40 and 70 ft2/ ac).
- An average pine basal area of pines < 25.4 cm (10 in) less than 4.6 m2/ha (20 ft2/ac).
- No hardwood midstory or if a hardwood midstory is present, it is sparse and less than 2.1 m (7 ft) in height.
- Total stand basal area, including overstory hardwoods, less than 23.0 m2/ha (80 ft2/ac).
- We recommend that all land counted as foraging habitat be within 0.4 km (0.25 mi) of the cluster, and that any stand counted as foraging habitat be within 61 m (200 ft) of another foraging stand or the cluster itself.
- Frequent prescribed burning of foraging habitat, especially during the growing season, is strongly recommended. Development and protection of herbaceous groundcovers facilitates prescribed burning and benefits red-cockaded woodpeckers
- The Recovery Standard. This standard is recommended for all populations on federal lands, state lands, and those populations on private lands being managed for increasing population size.
- Area Provided by Site Productivity.
- In systems of medium to high site productivity (site index 60 or more, for the dominant pine species), provide each group of woodpeckers 120 ac of good quality habitat.
- In systems of low site productivity (site index below 60, for the dominant pine species), provide each group of woodpeckers 200 to 300 ac of good quality habitat.
- ‘Good Quality Foraging Habitat’ has all of the following characteristics:
- 18 or more stems/ac of pines that are > 60 years in age and > 14 in dbh. Minimum basal area is 20 ft2 /ac.
- Basal area of pines 10 – 14 in dbh is between 0 and 40 ft2 /ac.
- Basal area of pines < 10 in dbh is below 10 ft2 /ac and below 20 stems/ac.
- Basal area of pines > 10 in dbh is at least 40 ft2 /ac. Minimum basal area in (i.) and (ii.) above is 40 ft2 /ac.
- Groundcovers of native bunchgrass and/or other native, fire-tolerant, fire-dependent herbs total 40% or more of ground and midstory plants and are dense enough to carry growing season fire at least once every 5 years.
- No hardwood midstory exists, or if hardwood midstory is present it is sparse and less than 2.1 m (7 ft) in height.
- Canopy hardwoods are absent or less than 10% of the number of canopy trees in longleaf forests (xeric oak inclusions not counted).
- All of this habitat is within 0.5 mi of the cluster center and 50% or more is within 0.25 mi of the cluster center.
- Foraging habitat is not separated by more than 200 ft of non-foraging areas (hardwood forest, pine stands < 30 years in age, cleared land such as agricultural lands or recently clearcut areas, paved roadways, utility ROW).
- Area Provided by Site Productivity.
Potentially Harmful Activities
- Projects within the southeastern United States that calls for removal of pine trees 30 years or older could have impacts to red-cockaded woodpecker; typically, such trees will be at least 25.4 cm (10 in) dbh or larger.
- Removing any red-cockaded woodpecker cavity tree, through cutting, bulldozing, or any other activity.
- Damaging an active cavity tree which results in the death of that tree. Damage includes, but is not limited to, injury to the bole or root system (generally due to heavy equipment use), exposure to herbicides, and fire scorch to the crown due to inadequate protective measures during prescribed burning. Pines are best protected from damage by intense fires through frequent low-intensity prescribed burns (see 8K, USFWS 2003).
- Using insecticides on any standing pine tree. Prevention and control of disease and insect infestations is encouraged. Infestations of insects such as southern pine beetles are best prevented by maintaining open structure and adequate spacing between pines (see 8J, USFWS 2003). Control of active infestations often includes the cutting of infested trees. If such control will result in losses of trees below recommended foraging guidelines, or in the removal of cavity trees, the Service must be contacted prior to the action.
- Constructing roads and utility rights-of-way within a cluster. Use of existing roads, improved or unimproved, generally does not adversely affect red-cockaded woodpeckers and therefore is permitted. If, in the landowner’s opinion, there is no reasonable alternative to construction of new roads, either improved or unimproved, or if there is no reasonable alternative to placing a utility right-of-way within the cluster, the Service must be contacted before construction or clearing activities are initiated.
- Construction of facilities including, but not limited to, buildings, campgrounds, recreational developments, residential dwellings, and industrial or business complexes. If, in the landowner's opinion, extenuating circumstances require a facility to be constructed in an active cluster, the Service must be contacted during the planning phase and prior to any construction activity.
- Planting of shrubs and/or ornamental plants that will exceed 2.1 m (7 ft) in height within 15.24 m (50 ft) of active and inactive cavity trees. If cavities are 3.05 m (10 ft) or less in height, planting any shrubs within 15.24 m (50 ft) of cavity trees may adversely affect red-cockaded woodpeckers. Construction equipment and construction material cannot be stored within 61 m (200 ft) of cavity trees. Landscaping within clusters should be accomplished with hand tools or lightweight power equipment rather than tractor mounted equipment.
Identification of Suitable Foraging Habitat
For the purpose of surveying, suitable foraging habitat consists of a pine or pine/hardwood stand of forest, woodland, or savannah in which 50 percent or more of the dominant trees are pines and the dominant pine trees are generally 30 years in age or older. These characteristics do not necessarily describe good quality foraging habitat (see 2E, 8I USFWS 2003); rather, this is a conservative description of potentially suitable habitat.
Identification of pine and pine/hardwood stands can be made using cover maps that identify pine and pine/hardwood stands, aerial photographs interpreted by standard techniques, or a field survey conducted by an experienced forester or biologist. Age of stands can be determined by aging representative dominant pines in the stands using an increment-borer and counting annual growth rings. Stand data describing size classes may be substituted for age if the average size of 30 year-old pines is known, i.e., at least 25.4 cm (10 in) dbh or larger, for the local area and habitat type.
If no suitable foraging habitat is present within the project area (that is, no pines 30 years or older will be impacted), then further evaluation is unnecessary and red-cockaded woodpeckers are considered absent. If the project area contains any suitable foraging habitat that will be impacted by the project, that habitat, if it contains any 60 year old trees or older, and all other suitable nesting habitat within 0.8 km (0.5 mi) of the project site, regardless of ownership, must be surveyed for the presence of red-cockaded woodpeckers.
Identification of Suitable Nesting Habitat
For the purpose of surveying, suitable nesting habitat consists of pine, pine/hardwood, and hardwood/pine stands that contain pines 60 years in age or older and that are within 0.8 km (0.5 mi) of the suitable foraging habitat to be impacted at the project site (see above). Additionally, pines 60 years in age or older may be scattered or clumped within younger stands; these older trees within younger stands must also be examined for the presence of red-cockaded woodpecker cavities. These characteristics do not necessarily describe good quality nesting habitat (see 2D, 8E, 8F); rather, this is a conservative description of potential nesting habitat.
Determination of suitable nesting habitat may be based on existing stand data, aerial photo interpretation, and/or field reconnaissance. All stands meeting the above description, regardless of ownership, are surveyed for cavity trees. Absence of suitable nesting habitat may support a no effect determination when indirect and cumulative effects are unlikely. Please discuss with the local USFWS Field Office if enough information is available to reach this determination.
Surveying for Red-cockaded Woodpecker Cavity Trees
Once suitable nesting habitat is identified (above), it must be surveyed for cavity trees of red-cockaded woodpeckers by personnel experienced in management and/or monitoring of the species. Surveys are acceptable any time of year, however it is recommended they occur during nesting season (April 1 – July 31). RCWs increase activity during nesting season, including releasing more sap around cavity entrances “candling”. The increased activity allows for easier identification for the surveyor. Potential nesting habitat is surveyed by running line transects through stands and visually inspecting all medium-sized and large pines for evidence of cavity excavation by red-cockaded woodpeckers. Transects must be spaced so that all trees are inspected. Necessary spacing will vary with habitat structure and season from a maximum of 91 m (100 yards) between transects in very open pine stands to 46 m (50 yards) or less in areas with dense midstory. Transects are run north-south, because many cavity entrances are oriented in a westerly direction, and can be set using a hand compass. When cavity trees are found, their location is recorded in the field using a Global Positioning System (GPS) unit, aerial photograph, and/or field map.
Activity status, cavity stage (start, advanced start, or complete cavity), and any entrance enlargement are assessed and recorded at this time. Again, it is extremely important to have all surveys and cavity tree assessments performed by experienced personnel. If cavity trees are found, more intense surveying within 457 m (1500 ft) of each cavity tree is conducted to locate all cavity trees in the area. Cavity trees are later assigned into clusters based on observations of red-cockaded woodpeckers as described in 3A (3A, USFWS 2003). Any cavity trees or other evidence of red-cockaded woodpecker activity is reported to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s South Carolina Ecological Services Field Office.
Resources
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 2003. Recovery plan for the red-cockaded woodpecker (Picoides borealis): second revision. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Atlanta, GA. 296 pp. https://www.fws.gov/rcwrecovery/recovery_plan.html
Conservation Measures for the General Public
- Remove Beach Equipment Daily: For tourist, residential or hotel operations, remove beach chairs, umbrellas, surfboards, and any other recreational items from the beach each day. Store these items in a designated area away from the nesting habitat to prevent obstruction or harm to sea turtles.
- Report Stranded Sea Turtles: If you encounter an injured or dead sea turtle on the beach, immediately call 1-800-922-5431 to report it.
- Respect Nesting Turtles and Tracks: If you see a nesting sea turtle at night, remain quiet and still at a safe distance. Sudden movement or noise can cause the turtle to abandon nesting and return to the ocean. If you find a crawl (tracks) or nest, do not disturb them. Tracks help identify the species and locate nests for protection. Never excavate or move a nest.
- Do Not Disturb Marked Nests: Do not remove or damage stakes, flagging, or other markers, even if they appear misplaced. These markers help biologists relocate nests if perimeter stakes are lost. Avoid using mechanical equipment or hand tools within the flagged buffer zone around a nest.
- Use Wildlife-Proof Trash Receptacles: Where feasible, install and maintain wildlife-proof trash containers to reduce the risk of attracting predators that may harm sea turtles or their eggs.
- Reduce Artificial Lighting: Turn off or shield beachfront lights visible from the beach at night during nesting season. Artificial light can disorient nesting females and hatchlings, leading them away from the ocean.
- Avoid Beach Driving: Do not drive vehicles on the beach during the nesting season, as this can obscure tracks, crush nests or hatchlings and compact sand, making nesting more difficult.
- Fill in Holes and Knock Down Sandcastles: Before leaving the beach, fill in any holes and flatten sand structures. These can trap hatchlings or obstruct nesting turtles.
- Keep Pets Off the Beach at Night: Pets can disturb nesting turtles or dig up nests. Follow local regulations regarding pets on beaches during the nesting season.
- Proper Disposal of Fishing Gear: Discard fishing lines, hooks, and nets responsibly. Entanglement is a major threat to sea turtles.
Conservation Measures for Ground-disturbing Activities
- Personnel Training: Before work begins, train all project personnel on the potential presence of nesting sea turtles and the actions required if they encounter a sea turtle or observe evidence of a nest, such as tracks or markers. Include information on legal protections under the Endangered Species Act of 1973 and advise personnel of the civil and criminal penalties for harming, harassing, or killing sea turtles.
- Beach-Compatible Fill: All material placed on the beach and in associated dune systems will consist of beach compatible sediment. Beach compatible fill is material that maintains the general character and functionality of the material occurring on the beach and in the adjacent dune and coastal system.
- Equipment Staging and Spill Prevention: Construction equipment (vehicles, machinery, pipe, other materials) will be stored, refueled, and maintained off the beach to the maximum extent practicable, or in areas devoid of vegetation and off the dune. Keep spill prevention and response materials on-site and ensure trained personnel are available. Dispose of spill cleanup waste properly and maintain a spill response log.
- Equipment Cleanliness: All vehicles, machinery, and equipment, including tools and personal protective equipment, must be clean, free of invasive species materials (e.g., plants/seeds, invertebrates, fungus), free of leaks, and in good working condition. Repair any leaks and clean equipment and construction vehicles thoroughly to remove any residual dirt, mud, debris, grease, motor oil, hydraulic fluid, coolant, or other hazardous substances before entering the work site or within the staging area. Ensure that all discharge, runoff, and/or harmful materials will be appropriately controlled to prevent entry into the project site.
- Site Access: Use existing roads for transport and access to the maximum extent possible. If vehicles must access the beach, restrict travel to the intertidal zone below the most recent high tide line to minimize sand compaction and impacts to dune vegetation.
- Nesting Season Protocol (May 1–October 31): Implement a nest monitoring and relocation plan during construction. Nesting surveys and nest relocation should be conducted by personnel with prior experience and training in nesting surveys and nest marking procedures and must have a valid South Carolina Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR) permit. Conduct daily patrols between sunrise and 9:00 AM in sand placement areas. Relocate nests only if they will be impacted by sand placement.
- Nest Relocation Guidelines: Nests should be relocated to an area suitable for both the Service and SCDNR and placed in areas where artificial lighting will not disorient hatchlings. Do not cluster nests, they should be randomly staggered along the length and width of the beach in areas that are not expected to experience daily inundation by high tides or known to routinely experience severe erosion and egg loss. Cease relocation when construction no longer threatens nests. Nests in areas where construction has ceased or will not occur for 75 days, or nests laid in the nourished berm, must be marked and left in place unless other risk exists. Install on-beach markers at the nest site and inspect daily to assure nest markers remain in place and the nest has not been disturbed by project activity. No activity will occur within ten square feet of the nest and a clear path seaward from the nest will be established and maintained.
- Nighttime Construction Measures (May 1–October 31):
- Pipeline Monitoring (May 1 to August 31): A nighttime monitor with a valid SCDNR permit must patrol the entire length of the pipeline and check access ramps over pipelines multiple times a night to make sure nesting females do not get stuck behind the pipeline. Monitors must escort construction vehicles (heavy equipment and crew/supply transport vehicles) driving on the beach between dusk and dawn outside of the active project area. Vehicles should stay along the waterline and not exceed 10 mph. If a nesting female approaches within 100 ft of active work, operations must shut down until she returns to the water or the nest is relocated.
- Nest & Hatchling Emergence Monitoring (July 1 onward): Monitors must check relocated nests nightly after 9 PM once they reach ≥45 days incubation until three nights after the first sign of emergence or the inventory of the nest contents. Monitors must correct any construction lighting visible from nest before hatchlings emerge.
- Nighttime Fill Limit: Do not advance fill more than 500 ft along shoreline between dusk and the following day until the daily nesting survey has been completed. Exceptions require a permitted nighttime monitor and preconstruction agreement.
- Lighting Management: Between May 1 to October 31, limit direct lighting of the beach and nearshore waters to the immediate construction area. Minimize lighting on equipment through reduction, shielding, lowering, and appropriate placement to avoid excessive illumination of the water’s surface and nesting beach while meeting safety standards. Shields must be affixed to the light housing and be large enough to block light beyond the work area. Night monitors must document and classify visible light sources (construction, residential, personal, etc.) and work with contractors/code enforcement to correct issues.
- Escarpment Management: Between May 1 to October 31, escarpments within the entire project area must be leveled daily at sunrise. Nighttime monitors will inspect turtle activity before leveling and remain on-site until complete. After construction and before the next nesting season (May 1) survey and level any escarpments >18 inches in height and ≥ 100 ft long to the natural beach profile. If leveling is needed during nesting season, coordinate with USFWS and/or SCDNR.
- Post-Construction Dune Stabilization: If dune stabilization is required, use native species and follow guidelines outlined in How to Build a Dune (https://des.sc.gov/sites/des/files/docs/Environment/docs/dunes_howto.pdf).
- Emergency Sandbag Use: Emergency sandbag placement must comply with SCDES Bureau of Coastal Management stipulations.
Avoidance and Minimization of Disturbance
- Avoid Disturbance to Birds: Do not disturb foraging or roosting seabirds and shorebirds including Rufa Red Knots, Piping Plovers, or Roseate Terns to the maximum extent practicable. A qualified biologist should survey the project area (operational site, access points, travel corridors, staging areas, etc.) for the presence of these species or for optimal habitat features such as inlets, bayside sand and mud flats, tidal pools, and wrack lines. Ensure all personnel are instructed on how to avoid these areas.
- Maintain Protective Buffers: When these species are present, do not allow vehicle or foot traffic within 150 feet of the birds or within 10 feet of optimal habitat features, even when birds are not present. Maintain these recommended buffers for the duration of work activities, even if the birds relocate. Personnel and vehicles should use existing travel or access corridors and move at slow speeds to avoid disturbance.
- Avoid High‑Tide Roosting Areas: Remain at least 500 feet away from high‑tide roosting areas, including large mixed-species flocks, as Rufa Red Knots and Piping Plovers often roost with other shorebirds. If birds repeatedly flush or fly away, increase your distance.
- Aircraft Restrictions Near Shorebird Areas: Do not fly aircrafts or drones below 500 feet near foraging or roosting areas. Avoid hovering or landing near open, unvegetated areas where shorebirds concentrate.
- Modify Structures to Reduce Predators: Ensure poles and pier pilings within 300 feet of shorebird use areas have pointed tops instead of flat surfaces to deter avian predators.
Project Travel, Access, and Movement
- Designate and Use Access Corridors: Establish access points and travel routes that avoid known foraging or roosting areas. Keep all personnel, vehicles, and equipment within these designated corridors. Install posts and rope where needed to clearly mark foraging and concentrated roosting sites.
- Minimize Shoreline Driving: Avoid driving along the shoreline to prevent disturbance to birds and prevent altering beach topography. Keep all activities with the established footprint and designated access routes.
- Use Equipment That Minimizes Beach Alteration: Use low-pressure tire vehicles (10 psi) or tracked equipment (ATVs, dozers) or consult with a qualified biologist appropriate alternatives to minimize impacts to beach topography.
- Site Access: Use existing roads for transport and access to the maximum extent possible. If vehicles must access the beach, restrict travel to the intertidal zone below the most recent high tide line to minimize sand compaction and impacts to dune vegetation.
Habitat Protection
- Protect the Wrack Line: Avoid disturbing the wrack line during project work or travel. If vehicles or equipment must cross it, gently rake the wrack aside to create a crossing corridor. Restore the wrack to its original condition once access is no longer needed.
- Protect Inlet/Soundside Flats and Dune Systems: Avoid disturbing sand and mud flats to the maximum extent practicable. Prevent impacts to all dune systems, including vegetated and unvegetated areas. Always use existing access corridors. If needed, establish a 10‑foot flagged buffer from the dune toe or vegetation line.
- Avoid High‑Value Inlet Habitats During Construction: Locate construction staging areas and pipeline routes to avoid high‑value inlet complex habitats for Piping Plovers and Rufa Red Knots to the maximum extent practicable.
Staging, Equipment Handling, and Materials
- Locate Staging and Waste Areas Appropriately: Site staging areas and waste collection zones away from beaches, dunes, inlets, and ephemeral tidal pools. Maintain a clean work site and remove all trash and work‑related debris daily.
- Equipment Staging and Spill Prevention: Construction equipment (vehicles, machinery, pipe, other materials) will be stored, refueled, and maintained off the beach to the maximum extent practicable, or in areas devoid of vegetation and off the dune. Keep spill prevention and response materials on-site and ensure trained personnel are available. Dispose of spill cleanup waste properly and maintain a spill response log.
- Equipment Cleanliness: All vehicles, machinery, and equipment, including tools and personal protective equipment, must be clean, free of invasive species materials (e.g., plants/seeds, invertebrates, fungus), free of leaks, and in good working condition. Repair any leaks and clean equipment and construction vehicles thoroughly to remove any residual dirt, mud, debris, grease, motor oil, hydraulic fluid, coolant, or other hazardous substances before entering the work site or within the staging area. Ensure that all discharge, runoff, and/or harmful materials will be appropriately controlled to prevent entry into the project site.
- Beach-Compatible Fill: All material placed on the beach and in associated dune systems will consist of beach compatible sediment. Beach compatible fill is material that maintains the general character and functionality of the material occurring on the beach and in the adjacent dune and coastal system.
Surveys, Assessments, and Biological Oversight
- Required Biological Surveys and Habitat Assessments: A qualified contractor will conduct abundance and distribution surveys, as well as pre‑ and post‑construction habitat quality assessments, for Piping Plovers and Rufa Red Knots for any project area located within one mile of an inlet.
- Personnel Training: Before work begins, train all project personnel on the potential presence of Rufa Red Knots, Piping Plovers, or Roseate Terns. Include information on legal protections under the Endangered Species Act of 1973 and advise personnel of the civil and criminal penalties for harming and harassing these species.
Post‑Construction and Emergency Measures
- Post-Construction Dune Stabilization: If dune stabilization is required, use native species and follow guidelines outlined in How to Build a Dune (https://des.sc.gov/sites/des/files/docs/Environment/docs/dunes_howto.pdf).
- Emergency Sandbag Use: Emergency sandbag placement must comply with SCDES Bureau of Coastal Management stipulations.
Pre-Project Planning
- Review State Natural Heritage data for historical and recent records. Lack of records in State Natural Heritage databases does not confirm absence. Assume potential presence in suitable habitat unless surveys confirm otherwise.
- Conduct species surveys before ground disturbance.
- For surveys a minimum of 3 surveys should be conducted during peak activity periods (late September–October and mid-May–June) using road cruising or drift fence camera arrays. Surveys should occur over two consecutive years where feasible.
- Incorporate avoidance zones for high-quality habitat and known occurrences into site plans. High-quality habitat includes xeric sandhills, longleaf pine–wiregrass communities, and well-drained sandy soils with sparse midstory vegetation.
Minimize Habitat Loss and Fragmentation
- Avoid clearing large, contiguous tracts of sandhill or longleaf pine habitat.
- Design projects to maintain habitat connectivity (e.g., wildlife corridors, buffer zones).
- Limit new road construction through suitable habitat; use existing roads where possible.
Protect Sandy Soils and Groundcover
- Restrict heavy equipment use to dry conditions and use low-pressure tires to reduce soil compaction. To the extent possible avoid use of heavy equipment during the active season (March – November).
- Avoid intensive site preparation (e.g., bedding, root raking) that destroys burrows and alters soil structure.
- Retain native herbaceous vegetation (e.g. wiregrass) that supports prey species.
Manage Underground Refugia
- Do not remove stumps, excavate burrows, or conduct subsurface root raking in suitable habitat.
- If excavation is unavoidable, implement pre-construction surveys and daily monitoring during ground disturbance, with a qualified biologist on-site to relocate snakes if encountered.
Fire and Vegetation Management
- Where feasible, integrate prescribed fire into long-term site management to maintain open-canopy conditions.
- If fire is impractical, use mechanical thinning or selective herbicide to reduce midstory vegetation without harming native groundcover. Mechanical thinning should be done during dormant season.
- To protect essential prey for southern hognose, avoid herbicide application in temporary wetlands that serve as toad breeding sites.
Control Invasive Species
- Ensure all equipment is cleaned of soil, seeds, and plant debris before entering new sites to prevent invasive species spread.
- Implement early detection and rapid response for cogongrass (Imperata cylindrica) to prevent habitat degradation and altered fire regimes.
- Reduce red imported fire ants through approved pest management strategies; minimize soil disturbance to prevent colonization.
- Manage feral hogs and free-ranging cats in coordination with wildlife agencies.
Construction Best Practices
- Use existing natural breaks (roads, trails, wetlands) for fire lines or project boundaries instead of creating new ones.
- Minimize creation of berms or fire lanes with heavy equipment to protect soil stability and burrow systems.
Education and Compliance
- Train contractors and personnel on species identification and BMPs.
- Post signage in sensitive areas to prevent unauthorized activities.
- Enforce prohibitions on killing or collecting snakes.