Poster
Abstracts
The Importance of Intake
Bar Spacing for Protecting Sturgeon at Hydropower Projects
Steve Amaral - Alden Research Laboratory, Inc., Holden,
MA
Description: Narrow bar spacings (less than or equal
to 2 inches) have been installed at many hydro
project intakes to reduce entrainment of fish through
turbines and, when combined with angled
structures, to guide them to downstream bypasses. The
ability of narrow bar spacings to prevent
entrainment is dependent on fish size and behavior and
approach velocities. Even when fish are small
enough to pass through a given bar spacing, many fish
will actively avoid entrainment through intake racks
as long as approach velocities are low enough for them
to escape. Additionally, the relatively small size
(less than 8 inches in length) of most fish that are
entrained at hydro projects (with and without narrow
bar spacing) usually results in high turbine survival
rates. Therefore, determining appropriate bar spacings
for any species or life stage should include estimation
of physical and behavioral exclusion associated with
proposed intake modifications, as well as estimates
of turbine passage survival for fish that are entrained.
These parameters can be estimated using existing data
describing bar rack exclusion efficiencies and
theoretical models developed for predicting turbine
passage survival. When combined with the
proportion of fish expected to pass over spillways for
the expected river flows during a migration season,
the bar rack exclusion and turbine survival estimates
can be used to calculate total downstream passage
survival for several bar spacings and a range of fish
lengths in order to assess relative effectiveness. A
dataset developed for shortnose sturgeon at a hydro
project in the Northeast will be presented to
demonstrate how such an analysis can be used for determining
appropriate bar spacings for effectively
protecting sturgeon species at any project.
A/OFRC Sturgeon Research
Curtis Avery - Anishinabek/Ontario Fisheries Resource
Center (A/OFRC), North Bay, ON
Description: First Nations throughout Ontario have
significant knowledge of and cultural ties to Lake
Sturgeon, particularly those First Nations whose territorial
boundaries border the Great Lakes basin. Of
the 38 First Nations that make up the UOI, 25 border
the Great Lakes basin (mainly Lake Huron and Lake
Superior) and 4 border watersheds that support Lake
Sturgeon populations. Since 1999, the A/OFRC has
partnered with 12 of these First Nations to complete
a total of 45 Lake Sturgeon research projects within
the Great Lakes basin. These projects varied from spring
spawning assessments, to open water netting,
telemetry tagging and monitoring, critical habitat classification,
and traditional ecological knowledge
studies. In northeastern Lake Superior, the A/OFRC has
worked in partnership with 3 First Nations,
provincial and federal government agencies, and universities
to gather traditional ecological knowledge
and design scientific research projects that combine
netting, radio telemetry, and habitat assessments on
three spawning tributaries (Pic River, White River,
and Michipicoten River). Results from these studies
have identified and assessed critical habitat, estimated
population abundance and characteristics,
monitored movement patterns and environmental cues,
and engaged communities in monitoring Lake
Sturgeon populations within their traditional territories.
This poster hopes to visualize such projects
completed by the A/OFRC throughout the Great Lakes Basin.
Environmental and Family
Effects on Lake Sturgeon Eggs and Larval Mortality and
Growth in a Streamside Facility
Nathan Barton1, John Bauman1, Kim Scribner1, and Edward
Baker2
1Department of Fisheries and Wildlife, Michigan State
University, East Lansing, MI
2Michigan Department of Natural Resources, Marquette,
MI
Description: Production hatcheries typically focus
on numbers of fish produced rather than fish quality,
including genetic diversity. Family effects on egg and
larval mortality and growth rates can influence
diversity and size of hatchery-reared fish. Rearing
fish in a streamside rearing facility (SRF) introduces
fish
during early life stages to a wider range of environmental
conditions, (i.e., temperature, dissolved oxygen,
turbidity) than would be experienced in a traditional
hatchery setting. Lake sturgeon (Acipenser
fulvescens) gametes were collected throughout the spawning
period from spawning adults (total N=41) in
the Black Lake, MI population over a four year period
(2009 – 2012). Gametes were fertilized using half-sib
crosses and were reared at ambient temperatures using
filtered river water. Egg mortality was recorded
daily, allowing for estimates of the timing and causes
of mortality. Digital photos of larvae (N=25/family)
were taken at hatch and once each week for three weeks
post-hatch. Image analysis software was used to
measure body size and yolk sac area (YSA). Temperature
was recorded hourly during egg incubation and
larval rearing. Egg mortalities were highest during
the first two trimesters of development. Larvae reared
in colder temperatures were larger at hatch and had
smaller YSA, than eggs reared in warmer
temperatures. Peaks in egg mortality were temperature-dependent
and varied significantly among
families. Family and temperature-dependent differences
in body size were also observed through the
three week post-hatch period, demonstrating important
genetic and environmental effects on allocation
of yolk resources to phenotypes that likely have important
consequences for survival.
Post hatch dispersal of lake sturgeon
(Acipenser fulvescens) larvae in relation to substrate
in an artificial stream
John Bauman - Michigan State University, East Lansing,
MI
Description: Knowledge of the effects of environment
and genotype on behavior during early ontogenetic
stages of many fish species including lake sturgeon
(Acipenser fulvescens) is generally lacking. Data are
particularly important at a time when human activities
are fundamentally altering habitats and seasonal
and diel physical and biotic stream features. We conducted
our experiment to quantify larval lake
sturgeon dispersal distance and stream substrate preference
using three day post-hatch larvae from
different females (N=2) whose eggs were incubated at
different temperatures (10oC and 18oC) simulating
stream conditions during early and late spawning and
incubation periods in the Black River, MI. Data
revealed that three day post-hatch larvae exhibited
considerable variability in dispersal distance as a
function of family (genotype), temperature experienced
during previous (embryonic) ontogenetic stages,
and environmental ‘grain’. Larval dispersal
distances three days post hatch varied as a function
of the
juxtaposition of substrate to location of egg hatch.
Larval lake sturgeon dispersed to and settled
exclusively in gravel substrate. Larval dispersal distance
also varied as a function of family and egg
incubation temperatures reflecting differences in offspring
body size and levels of endogenous yolk
reserves (yolk sac area) at hatch. Expression of plasticity
in larval dispersal behavior may be particularly
important to individual survival and population levels
of recruitment contingent upon the location, size,
and degree of fragmentation of suitable (gravel) habitats
between adult spawning and larval rearing areas.
Effects of prophylactic
pathogen abatement treatments on larval lake sturgeon
survival in stream-side
facilities
John Bauman - Michigan State University, East Lansing,
MI
Description: Stream-side facilities for lake sturgeon
(Acipenser fulvescens) utilize a natal water source
exposing larvae to natural temperature fluctuations
as well as chemical attributes believed to be
associated with imprinting. However, stream-side rearing
also increases exposure of larvae to microbial
communities which include potential fish pathogens.
We quantified rates of larval survival in multiple
production families and from larvae captured during
evening stream drift assessments based on exposure
to two prophylactic treatments (hydrogen peroxide and
salt) for 30 days following the initiation of
exogenous feeding. The use of hydrogen peroxide reduced
mortality while salt had no significant effect
on survival. Prophylactic treatments may help managers
to reach stocking goals for lake sturgeon in the
Great Lakes.
The Role of Resource Managers
in Education & Outreach Planning: Implications for
successful fisheries projects
Mary Bohling – Michigan Sea Grant, Michigan State
University Extension, Lincoln Park, MI
Elizabeth LaPorte - Michigan Sea Grant, University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI
Description: Successful projects require careful planning,
implementation, monitoring and
evaluation. However, public outreach and education,
though often overlooked, can be equally important
elements of successful projects when used to extend
and enhance natural resources projects. A number
of natural resource managers have developed multi-disciplinary
teams that include scientists as well as
outreach and education professionals who provide information
about Michigan’s coastal Great Lakes
areas to residents, schools and others through workshops,
public events, presentations, publications,
websites, displays and targeted communications. Science-based
outreach tools can greatly enhance and
extend research efforts and help key audiences, including
potential future supporters understand why an
issue may be important. Outreach efforts are designed
to foster science-based decisions about the use
and conservation of Great Lakes resources. These efforts
can also aid in developing new partnerships,
support for future projects and increased funding. Examples
from Michigan Sea Grant’s work on several
Huron to Erie Corridor projects will be used to demonstrate
the positive impacts of incorporation of
education and outreach.
Lake Sturgeon Restoration in
the Upper St. Louis River, MN
Brian Borkholder and Tom Howes - Fond du Lac Band of
Lake Superior Chippewa, Cloquet, MN
Description: In the mid 1990’s, Fond du Lac Resource
Management Department (FCLRMD) began planting
lake sturgeon eggs obtained from cooperative efforts
with USFWS Ashland FRO, WIDNR, and MIDNR.
After several years of assessments, no sturgeon were
ever located. When VHS hit the Great Lakes, the
egg-stocking efforts came to a halt. Beginning in the
late 2000’s, anecdotal reports of sturgeon being
angled began trickling thru the rumor mill. FDLRMD began
an assessment blitz using gill nets and angling
to see if lake sturgeon could be located. Three years
into the project, we have over a dozen sturgeon
fitted with transmitters and are documenting habitat
use within the river. Genetic analysis has confirmed
that these sturgeon did originate from the parent stocks
used as the egg source during the original
stocking efforts. FDLRMD plans on resurrecting the stocking
of eggs / fry beginning soon to supplement
this population with additional year classes as we continue
to press towards a fully-restored population on
the upper St. Louis River and Reservation waters.
Evaluation of Larval
Lake Sturgeon Production near an Artificial Spawning
Reef (Fighting Island Reef) in the Detroit River
Emily Bouckaert - Michigan Technological University,
Houghton, MI
Description: In 2008, an artificial spawning reef was
constructed near Fighting Island in the Detroit River
to
enhance spawning habitat for native fishes including
lake sturgeon (Acipenser fulvescens). In this system,
much of the natural lake sturgeon spawning habitat has
been degraded or eliminated as a result of
channelization, dredging, and substrate removal. The
Fighting Island reef consists of 12 experimental reef
beds containing four different substrate treatments.
In 2012, reef beds composed of different substrates
were sampled for fish larvae in order to evaluate the
effectiveness of this artificial reef project. We
detected the presence of lake sturgeon eggs on all substrate
types on 9 May, and began larval lake
sturgeon sampling using D-Frame drift nets on 15 May.
We focused larval sampling efforts on the four
reefs closest to Fighting Island where we found the
highest egg densities. Night sampling (20:00-06:00
hrs) was conducted biweekly until 5 June. In total,
30 lake sturgeon larvae were collected directly
downstream of the four reef beds and 3larvae were collected
upstream in control sites. Approximately
45.5% of the larvae were collected on the 15 May, and
zero larvae were collected on 5 June. A repeated
measures ANOVA found no significant difference in average
CPUEs (larval sturgeon/hr/night) between
sampling sites located directly downstream of the four
reef bed treatments. Our results indicate that the
Fighting Island reef is producing viable lake sturgeon
larvae. While our sampling effort in such a large
system is small, larval drift downstream of each substrate
type was documented.
Using Commercial Fisheries
Tagging Data to Assess the Status of Lake Sturgeon in
Saginaw Bay, Michigan
Justin Chiotti - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Waterford,
MI
Adam Kowalski - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Alpena,
MI
Lloyd Mohr - Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources,
Owen Sound, ON
Description: In an effort to better understand the
status of lake sturgeon in Saginaw Bay, Michigan, the
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service initiated a project in
1995 utilizing the voluntary participation of commercial
fishers who encounter lake sturgeon as by-catch in their
fisheries. To date, 357 individual lake sturgeon
have been tagged by commercial fisherman in Saginaw
Bay. We utilized tagging information collected in
1995-2011 to make inferences on the demographics of
lake sturgeon in the bay. Individual fish capture
histories were input into MARK to estimate the number
of lake sturgeon utilizing the bay and apparent
survival. Of the 357 originally tagged fish, 22 have
been recaptured once in a different year and three
have been recaptured in two different years. The number
of lake sturgeon utilizing the bay is estimated to
be 2,881 (95% CI = 2041 – 4139). Apparent survival
estimates were much lower than what has been
reported in other systems < 70%, suggesting temporary
emigration out of the bay. Concurrent markrecapture
studies by the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources
(OMNR) in Southern Lake Huron have
recaptured 11 lake sturgeon initially tagged in Saginaw
Bay. Thirteen lake sturgeon initially tagged by
OMNR in Southern Lake Huron near Port Huron, MI (out
of 1,657 tagged total) were recaptured in
Saginaw Bay. Data suggests a substantial amount of movement
between these two stocks; however
additional tagging is needed to better understand interactions
between these stocks.
Lake Sturgeon Population
Demographics in the Detroit/St. Clair System, 1996-2012
Justin Chiotti - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Waterford,
MI
Lloyd Mohr - Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources,
Owen Sound, ON
Michael Thomas - Michigan Department of Natural Resources,
Harrison Township, MI
James Boase - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Waterford,
MI
Bruce Manny - U.S. Geological Survey, Ann Arbor, MI
Description: The Detroit/St. Clair System, encompassing
Southern Lake Huron, St. Clair River, Lake St. Clair,
Detroit River, and Western Lake Erie contains one of
the largest lake sturgeon populations in the Great
Lakes. Here we present population demographic information
describing the status of three different
spawning stocks in this system over the last sixteen
years. Mark-recapture assessments conducted in
1996-2012 have resulted in 1,657, 1,483, and 214, individually
tagged lake sturgeon in Southern Lake
Huron, North Channel of the St. Clair River, and Detroit
River, respectively. Individual fish capture
histories were input into POPAN and Pradel models in
MARK to estimate stock size, apparent survival, and
seniority. The estimated adult population size for the
Southern Lake Huron stock is 35,484 (95% CI =
25,939 – 45,030), followed by the North Channel
of the St. Clair River 11,720 (95% CI = 7,356 –
16,083),
and Detroit River 4,068 (95% CI = 869 – 7,268).
Seniority probability (?) estimates were > 0.50 during
all
years but one, demonstrating the importance of adult
survival in maintaining these stocks. Adult apparent
survival estimates ranged between 60 - 71% for the North
Channel of the St. Clair River stock and 68 –
71%
for the Southern Lake Huron stock. Movement throughout
the system may account for low apparent
survival estimates observed. Mark-recapture data has
provided valuable information regarding the
Detroit/St. Clair System lake sturgeon population; however
additional assessment is needed to further
understand the status of these stocks.
U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service’s
Coastal Program Helps Lake Sturgeon
Christie Deloria-Sheffield - U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service, Marquette, MI
Description: Over the last several years, the U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service’s Coastal Program has
actively
engaged with Lake Sturgeon partners. The poster will
summarize work completed or initiated through the
Coastal Program and highlight points of contact for
the program. The purpose is to ensure sturgeon
partners are aware of the Coastal Program, engage with
new partners, and identify priority projects for
future years.
Milestones in NY Lake
Sturgeon Restoration
Dawn Dittman - U.S. Geological Survey, Cortland, NY
Description: This will be a description of the recent
milestones in Lake Sturgeon in New York. These will
include numbers and size distributions in target waters
and the current reproductive status of the stocked
fish.
Lake Sturgeon Management
Cooperator Patch and Handling Guide
David Dortman - Sturgeon for Tomorrow, St. Clair -
Detroit River, Burtchville, MI
Description: St. Clair-Detroit River Sturgeon for Tomorrow
(SDR-SFT) is a non-profit organization that was
formed in 2010 by a group of lake sturgeon anglers in
Southeast Michigan. In following our mission to
perpetuate lake sturgeon by assisting fisheries managers,
the board of directors approved the designing
and funding of a Lake Sturgeon Management Cooperator
Patch in 2011 to encourage anglers to report
tagged lake sturgeon. The patch was provided to the
Michigan Department of Natural Resources, Lake St.
Clair Fisheries Research Station for distribution to
anglers who report tagged lake sturgeon information.
In
2012, SDR-SFT developed a 2 page brochure to educate
anglers on best practices to follow when handling
and releasing lake sturgeon. The guide also provides
information on recommended equipment to be
prepared to fish for lake sturgeon, and contact information
to report tagged fish. The guide was closely
modeled after guidelines published by the Minnesota
Department of Natural Resources. This poster was
developed by SDR-SFT with the assistance of Michael
Thomas with Michigan Department of Natural
Resources, Lake St. Clair Fisheries Research Station,
and Justin Chiotti with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service.
Immune Cells in the Brain
of Larval Lake Sturgeon
Barbara Evans and Jun Li - Lake Superior State University,
Sault Ste Marie, MI
Description: Melanomacrophage aggregate systems or
centers (MMC’s) are observed in vertebrates liver,
kidney and spleen tissue. They function as a component
of the immune system that can be stationary or
mobile throughout various organs. They are normally
present with infection within the organism, and
have been observed to encapsulate the pathogen. However,
our aggregates of immune cells are being
found in healthy larval lake sturgeon (Acipenser fulvescens)
from relatively pristine tributaries in the upper
Great Lakes. This study centers on identification, and
speculates on the purpose of these immune cells.
The MMCs were first observed in a 10 day post hatch
(dph) living specimen from a Lake Superior tributary
(Sturgeon River MI). Using video-microscopy, these small
(@75 micron), pigmented structures were
observed moving around inside the ventricle of the sturgeon
brain. The following year, lake sturgeon eggs
from a Lake Huron tributary (Black River MI) were obtained
shortly after fertilization, preserved for light
microscopy at selected developmental stages, cross-sectioned
at 3 microns and stained with cresyl violet.
The MMCs were found to be present at hatching, and composed
of dendritic and macrophage immune
cells, as well as melanin granules. Lake sturgeon from
a Lake Michigan tributary (Big Manistee River MI)
also contained these structures in 80% of the observed
larvae. To our knowledge, MMCs within the
ventricle of the brain of larval lake sturgeon have
not previously been reported. More in-depth studies
are
required to understand the function of these immune
cell clusters within healthy fish.
Population dynamics of
lake sturgeon in the lower Niagara River: revisiting
and reassessing a recovering population 10 years later.
Dimitry Gorsky - US Fish and Wildlife Service, Basom,
NY
Description: Evidence from assessments carried out
in the lower Niagara River between 1998 and 2002
suggested that the lake sturgeon population may be recovering.
During that assessment less than 100
lake sturgeon were sampled. Many of them were observed
to be young and sexually immature fish.
There appeared to be a lack of older, sexually mature
fish prompting the investigators to believe this
population was in recovery and awaiting the onset of
sexual maturity to continue the recovery. In 2012,
we began a population assessment of this population
using similar methods and locations as the previous
assessment. During our assessments, we observed much
higher catch rates and a shift in the age
structure toward older fish that appear to be of the
same cohort that was sampled in the earlier
assessment. We also observed a lack of older fish, but
did observe several sexually mature fish. Analysis
of population measures, catch rates and habitat use
gives us a closer understanding of the lake sturgeon
population in the lower Niagara River and insight into
how relict populations may undergo recovery.
Population status of lake
sturgeon in the Muskegon River, Michigan.
Brandon Harris, Garden Valley State University, Annis
Water Resources Institute, Muskegon, MI
A.C. Wieten, M.E.L. Altenritter, C.R. Ruetz, and K.M.
Smith.
Description: The Muskegon River is a Lake Michigan
tributary that supports a remnant population of lake
sturgeon (Acipenser fulvescens). We have been working
to assess the status of this population since 2008.
Each spring we sample adult lake sturgeon via gill netting
in Muskegon Lake and boat electrofishing in the
Muskegon River. We sampled juveniles with gill nets
in Muskegon Lake each year during August-
December. Finally, we sampled larval drift in the Muskegon
River to assess reproductive success. Agestructure
analysis of captured lake sturgeon (n=116; mean age
= 11.4) indicates 24 year classes are
represented among the individuals captured vial gill
netting and boat electrofishing, with the age of the
majority (91.5 % of aged fish) of individuals less than
21 years. The number of adults in the annual
spawning run is relatively low, with the number of adults
captured during any given year ranging from 9 to
49. Larval lake sturgeon were successfully captured
in 2009-2011 (n = 50; range = 13.0-21.5 mm total
length). Juvenile lake sturgeon were captured each year
of the study in Muskegon Lake (n = 138; range =
23.1 to 108.5 cm total length). Our results suggest
the spawning run in the Muskegon River is small,
although the abundance of the population appears to
be growing.
Sex, maturity, and changing
spawner demographics of lake sturgeon in the lower Niagara
River
Gregory R. Jacobs - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service,
Lamar, PA
Molly A. H. Webb - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Bozeman,
MT
Dimitry Gorsky - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Basom,
NY
John A. Sweka - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Lamar,
PA
Description: Evidence suggests that the lake sturgeon
population in the lower Niagara River is recovering,
largely driven by a small number of large cohorts from
the mid-late 1990s. Based on estimated ages from
pectoral fin ray samples, there was a predominance of
lake sturgeon aged 12-17 years in this population
during 2012. As fish from these cohorts reach maturity,
changes in the sex ratio and age composition of
spawning lake sturgeon are expected to occur over the
next several years, given differences in maturation
and spawning periodicity among sexes. As such, these
changes can have important implications for
population growth, or even persistence, we began monitoring
the age, sex, and maturation stage of lake
sturgeon in the lower Niagara River during spring of
2012. To assign sex and maturation stage, we
quantified the concentration of testosterone and 17ß-estradiol
in blood serum samples using
radioimmunoassay. We then confirmed blood plasma results
and quantified error rates using histological
analysis of gonad biopsies. Ages were estimated by enumerating
annuli from cross-sections of the leading
pectoral fin rays. Our results depict a snapshot of
the lower Niagara River lake sturgeon spawning
population in 2012, providing us with important baseline
estimates of age and sex ratio of spawning fish
which can be combined with mark-recapture assessment,
genetic analyses, and further monitoring to
construct population viability models.
Modeling the effect of
hydroelectric operations on sturgeon habitat in the
Spanish River
Bruce Kilgour1, Michael Davies2, Neil MacDonald2, Julien
Cousineau2, Cameron Portt3, Carolyn Hunt4.
1 Kilgour & Associates Ltd., Ottawa, ON
2 Coldwater Consulting Ltd., Ottawa, ON
3 C. Portt and Associates, Guelph, ON
4 Vale Canada Ltd., Sudbury, ON
Description: A large Lake Sturgeon population spawns
in the vicinity of Espanola Falls on the Spanish River.
The quantity and quality of sturgeon spawning habitat
is influenced by operations at three hydroelectric
generating stations (Big Eddy GS, Nairn GS, Lorne Falls
GS) upstream of Espanola, as well as operations at
Espanola Falls. A TELEMAC hydrodynamic model was calibrated
for the river system under two flow
regimes, then used to estimate water depth and flow
velocities for the receiving environment
downstream of Espanola Falls for the sturgeon spawning
periods in each year from 2001 to 2011.
Hydrodynamics were modeled for four operational scenarios
(flow regimes) that included: (1) existing
conditions (i.e., modest peaking); (2) smoothed peaking;
(3) run-of-river; and (4) naturalized flow regime.
The hydrodynamic model results were then used as input
to a spawning habitat suitability model that
considered flow velocities, water depth and substrate
texture, and predicted conditions for pixels of ~6 m2
in size. The model also considers water temperature,
the timing of spawning, and the likelihood that eggs
will go dry because of variations in water elevations.
Approximately 6.6% of the high-quality spawning
habitat has the potential to go dry under existing operational
scenarios because of fluctuations in
discharge through the turbines. Operating as run-of-river
(with hourly fluctuations) would reduce the
affected spawning areas to 5.9%, while operating without
hourly fluctuations would reduce the affected
areas to 0.7%, and operating as a more naturalized system
would reduce the affected areas to 0.3%.
Lake Michigan Lake Sturgeon
Streamside Rearing Partnership
Lead Author: Lake Michigan Lake Sturgeon Task Group
Project Cooperators:
Manistee River Facility
– Marty Holtgren, Little River Band of Ottawa
Indians, Manistee, MI.
– Steve Fajfer, Wisconsin Department of Natural
Resources, Wild Rose, WI.
Cedar River Facility and Whitefish River Facility
– Ed Baker, Michigan Department of Natural Resources,
Marquette, MI.
Milwaukee River Facility
– Brad Eggold, Wisconsin Department of Natural
Resources, Milwaukee, WI.
– Mary Holleback, River Edge Nature Center, Newburg,
WI
Kewaunee River Facility
– Mike Baumgartner, Wisconsin Department of Natural
Resources, Kewaunee, WI.
Kalamazoo River Facility
– Kregg Smith, Michigan Department of Natural
Resources, Plainwell, MI.
– Doug Aloisi, US Fish &Wildlife Service,
Genoa, WI.
Black River Research Facility
– Kim Scribner, Michigan State University, East
Lansing, MI.
– Ed Baker, Michigan Department of Natural Resources,
Marquette, MI.
Overall Project
– Rob Elliott and Kevin Mann, US Fish & Wildlife
Service, Green Bay, WI.
Description: Lake sturgeons still persist in at least
9 rivers tributary to Lake Michigan but at a fraction
of
their historic abundance. In 2002, a multi-group partnership
initiated a lake-wide assessment of the status
of these remnant populations which led to the identification
of rehabilitation needs and the development
of genetic guidelines for the stocking of lake sturgeon.
Consistent with these guidelines, streamside
rearing was first initiated in Lake Michigan on the
Manistee River in 2004 and has since expanded to a
total of 6 rivers as a means to reintroduce sturgeon
to rivers where extirpated or to rehabilitate existing
populations. An important aspect of streamside rearing
is the direct use of river water for incubation and
rearing in hopes that young sturgeon will imprint to
the target waters and eventually return to spawn in
the rivers where they were reared and stocked, thus
reducing the chance for unwanted genetic
consequences associated with straying of stocked fish.
Over a 4-6 month period, sturgeon are reared to
sizes of 100-200 mm, tagged with PIT tags and/or CWTs
and fin clips, and released into the target river
during late summer and fall of their first growing season.
Since 2004, 17,432 lake sturgeon fingerlings
have been released from the 6 streamside facilities
operating on Lake Michigan. Over the next 25 years,
researchers will evaluate the return of these fish to
the stocked rivers and monitor population growth and
maintenance of genetic diversity necessary for long-term
sustainability.
Assessment of larval
lake sturgeon (Acipenser fulvescens) production and
drift periodicity on the
Menominee River, Wisconsin
Dave Lawrence - University of Wisconsin, Green Bay,
WI
Description: Lake sturgeon larvae were sampled below
the North American Hydro dam on the Menominee
River for the 2012 drift season. Ten drift nets were
deployed in approximately the same position and
evenly spaced along a 200 meter wide transect, 800 meters
downstream from the Menominee Dam, two
additional nets were deployed in an elevated position,
0.5 m above the river bottom. A total of 374 lake
sturgeon larvae were captured, with two distinctive
peaks in larval drift activity observed. A total of
201
lake sturgeon larvae were captured during the first
peak of larval drift (5/14-5/18), and 173 lake sturgeon
larvae were collected during the second peak (5/27-6/1).
The peak of drift each night was consistently
between 21:00 and 22:00 hours. Based on water temperature
data, the spawning events that contributed
to the peaks of larval production occurred on approximately
4/16 and 5/17, respectively. Most larval lake
sturgeon larvae were captured in the middle of the stream
and near the Wisconsin shore. Both elevated
nets were productive, with one capturing the largest
number of larvae during 2012, (n=49). There was a
statistically significant correlation between average
river velocity at each net and the number of lake
sturgeon larvae captured, (p < 0.05; R?? = 0.424).
Lake Sturgeon Restoration
in the Central Great Lakes
Bruce Manny1, Jim Boase2, Greg Kennedy1, Ed Roseman1,
Richard Drouin3, Jacquelyn Craig1, David Bennion1,
Jen Read4, Lynn Vaccaro4 and Mike Thomas5
1 U.S. Geological Survey, U.S. Geological Survey, Ann
Arbor, MI
2 U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, Waterford, MI
3 Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, Wheatley, ON
4 Michigan Sea Grant, Ann Arbor, MI
5 Michigan Department of Natural Resources, Harrison
Township, MI
Description: Lake sturgeon were once abundant in the
St. Clair and Detroit Rivers. Owing to construction
of commercial shipping channels in the early 1900’s,
much of the spawning habitat for lake sturgeon was
destroyed in these rivers. An early study found only
2 of 9 reputed sturgeon spawning sites in the Detroit
River had enough clean, layered, rock rubble for successful
reproduction (McClain and Manny 2000). Since
2003, as part of the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative,
two fish spawning reefs have been constructed in
the Detroit River (1.1 ac total) and one such reef has
been constructed in the St. Clair River (1.0 ac). Lake
sturgeon have reproduced at Fighting Island in the Detroit
River and at the Middle Channel reef in the
lower St. Clair River. Here we present how and of what
materials the spawning reefs were constructed,
evidence to date of lake sturgeon reproduction at two
of the reefs, the geo-spatial model we developed to
select where to construct more spawning habitat, and
our plans to construct more sturgeon spawning
habitat in these rivers. Lastly, we place our results
in context with restoration of lake sturgeon populations
in the central Great Lakes.
Lake Sturgeon Habitat
in the White River
Keith Nahwegahbow - Anishinabek/Ontario Fisheries Resource
Centre, North Bay, ON
Description: This poster shows the study of Lake Sturgeon
movements and habitat utilization via radio
telemetry on the White River. The use of the SonarTRX,
side imaging sonar, to identify critical habitat and
the development of a habitat suitability model of critical
Lake Sturgeon habitat on the White River.
This poster includes:
1. Objectives of the study and the importance of habitat
for Lake Sturgeon
2. Methods: process of collecting sonar data (transects,
date, pictures/maps? etc), processing of sonar
data that was collected (sonarTRX, ArcGIS, Suitability
Modelling)
3. Results:
a. Substrate map of the White River
b. Bathymetric map of the White River
c. Locations of radio tagged Lake Sturgeon to identify
the substrate and depth preferences of
Lake Sturgeon in the White River
d. Lake Sturgeon suitability map of the White River
based on substrate type and depth
suitability index scores
e. Estimate length of time to collect/process data
f. And where were Lake Sturgeon most frequently observed
4. Discussion: how useful is this method? How could
it be improved? Advantages/disadvantages?
Implications?
Prioritizing barrier removal
to restore access to historical riverine spawning grounds
Thomas Neeson1, Peter McIntyre1, Stephanie Januchowski-Hartley1,
Matthew Diebel2, Patrick Doran3, and
Jesse O’Hanley4
1 Center for Limnology, University of Wisconsin, Madison,
WI USA
2 Wisconsin Dept. of Natural Resources, Madison, WI
USA
3 The Nature Conservancy, Lansing, MI USA
4 Management Science Group, University of Kent, Canterbury,
UK
Description: A key challenge in lake sturgeon restoration
is their limited access to historical riverine
spawning grounds, which are often upstream of barriers
(dams, road-stream crossings). The removal or
modification of instream barriers can restore migratory
pathways for sturgeon and other important
species, but the costs (economic, species invasions)
and benefits (access to breeding habitats) differ
among potential projects. The restoration community
lacks a transparent method for comparing these
costs and benefits to assess which barrier removal projects
would offer the greatest return on investment.
To address this problem, we are undertaking a three-step
project with the goal of providing a decision
support tool for prioritizing barriers for removal.
First, we have developed the most comprehensive
database to date of the location of dams (n=7,091) and
road-stream crossings (n=268,818) in the Great
Lakes Basin. Second, we have created a predictive statistical
model to estimate the passability of each of
these potential barriers for fishes. Third, we are currently
developing mathematical optimization models
to determine optimal barrier removal sequences to enhance
the amount of breeding habitat made
available for a given budget. We will discuss the key
factors that drive barrier prioritization, future data
needs, and the strengths and limitations of applying
optimization approaches to enhance lake sturgeon
restoration efforts.
North American
Sturgeon and Paddlefish Society
Affiliation: North American Sturgeon and Paddlefish
Society
Enhancing Michigan’s
virtual and place-based educational opportunities and
community stewardship
using charismatic lake sturgeon in coupled human - Great
Lakes ecosystems
Kim Scribner and John Bauman - Department of Fisheries
and Wildlife Michigan State University, East
Lansing, MI
Description: Educating K-12 students and the general
public about Great Lakes ecosystems and interdependencies
between fish communities and physical and biological
processes of streams used seasonally
for spawning and foraging is critical to increase awareness
of the need for stewardship activities. We have
developed a virtual (e-learning) web site based on 12
years of data collected on the lake sturgeon
population in Black Lake, MI. The site contains extensive
background information on lake sturgeon
ecology through all life stages. Science, technology
and math curricula have been developed that are
based on empirical long-term data from the Black Lake
Project.
Biological Characteristics
of Lake Sturgeon in Traditionally Fished Waters of Lake
Nipigon Sampled in 2006, 2007, 2008, and 2009
Kim Tremblay - Anishinabek/Ontario Fisheries Resource
Centre, North Bay, ON
Description: Since time immemorial, Lake Sturgeon (Acipenser
fulvescens) has been an important cultural
and subsistence fish species for Biinjitiwaabik Zaaging
Anishinaabek (BZA) First Nation. Lake Nipigon is a
large (484 800 ha), deep, remote lake that provides
a unique refuge for Lake Sturgeon. However, little is
known about the health and biological characteristics
of the Lake Nipigon Sturgeon. Local knowledge of
spring and fall Lake Sturgeon locations lead to the
capture of 135 Lake Sturgeon over a four year period.
With the targeted sets, the probability of capturing
a Lake Sturgeon was greatest in 10-15 m and lowest in
0 - 5 m of water. The analysis showed that the number
of Lake Sturgeon captured increases as depth
increases, and that the size of the Lake Sturgeon also
increases with depth. This study determined that
Lake Sturgeon were residing in the traditionally known
areas in the fall. Another result from this project
came from a recaptured Lake Sturgeon reported by a fisherman.
A Lake Sturgeon that was tagged in the
main basin by the Namewaminikan River was recaptured
in the Little Jackfish River. The recapture of a
Lake Sturgeon in the Little Jackfish River shows that
this tributary has value as Lake Sturgeon habitat.
Traditional knowledge provided by Elders Harold Michon
and Frank Goodman was invaluable to the
success of this project. I am grateful to Tim Haxton,
Aquatic Science Unit of the Ontario Ministry of Natural
Resources, who provided much assistance with the statistical
analysis of this data.
Preliminary assessment
of Lake Sturgeon spawning and larval drift in the St.
Marys River
Stefan Tucker, Troy Pine, Roger Greil, and Ashley Moerke
- Aquatic Research Laboratory, Lake Superior
State University, Sault Ste Marie, MI
Description: Previous research suggests that the Lake
Sturgeon population in the St. Marys River may be
vulnerable to catastrophic events due to a small resident
population size as well as lack of confirmed
spawning and early life stages (e.g., larvae or juveniles).
Only adult and sub-adult Lake Sturgeon have been
collected in the St. Marys River and it is currently
unclear if the population is successfully self-sustaining.
A
study was conducted during spring-summer 2012 in the
Garden River and the Soo Locks Unit 10 tailrace to
confirm Lake Sturgeon reproduction in the St. Marys
River system. Egg mats (tailrace only) and overnight
sets of larval drift nets were used to document lake
sturgeon reproduction at both locations. Water
temperature, depth and flow also were recorded. Eight
larval Lake Sturgeon were captured in the Garden
River between May 24-29, corresponding to temperatures
of 18-20oC, but no eggs or larval sturgeon were
collected in the tailrace. Although reproduction was
never confirmed in the tailrace, adult sturgeon
activity was observed in the study site. Further sampling
will be conducted in spring-summer 2013 to
identify important spawning locations and quantify larval
drift in the Garden River.
Building a Future for Lake Sturgeon
through Fish Passage
Nick Utrup - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, New Frankin,
WI
Description: Great Lakes lake sturgeon populations
have been slow to recover since their decline in the
late 1800s due to habitat destruction, dam construction,
and overfishing. Most tributaries to Lake
Michigan that were important to sturgeon contain dams
that block access to historic spawning and rearing
habitat. The Menominee River contains the largest of
Lake Michigan’s nine remaining wild lake sturgeon
populations. However, this population is still severely
depressed and dams continue to fragment the
population and prevent fish from completing their traditional
migration to and from Lake Michigan.
Through years of focused research and planning, the
Menominee River Fish Passage Partnership (U.S. Fish
and Wildlife Service, Wisconsin Department of Natural
Resources, Michigan Department of Natural
Resources, North American Hydro, River Alliance of Wisconsin
and Michigan Hydro Relicensing Coalition),
have determined that Menominee River lake sturgeon are
an important and genetically distinct
population critical to sturgeon recovery in Lake Michigan.
The Fish Passage Partnership has determined
that safe and effective upstream and downstream passage
around the lower two dams on the river is
needed for the population to reach healthy and sustainable
levels. Science, planning, and teamwork have
resulted in development of the very first fish passage
in North America designed for lake sturgeon, which
should be completed by 2015.
International Sturgeon
Symposium 7 – Nanaimo, BC, July 2013
Affiliation: Vancouver Island University and the World
Sturgeon Conservation Society